Closing the door on immigrants
President Donald Trump isn’t opposed to only illegal immigration; he opposes most legal immigration as well.
Figures from 2017 and the first half of 2018 show that the number of legal immigrants to the United States is on course to decline about 12 percent in Trump’s first two years in office, according to an analysis by the Washington Post.
The numbers for refugees – immigrants fleeing violence, persecution and death – tell a sadder story, according to the Pew Research Center. The number of refugees allowed to come to the U.S. dropped from 97,000 in 2016 to 33,000 in 2017.
The immigration trends, coupled with White House proposals for even more drastic reductions, run counter to good social and economic policy.
They damage our nation’s ability to remain strong, innovative and adaptive in a world that will continue to change – whether we want it to or not.
And they come as Trump and his relatives continue to hire foreign workers for low-wage jobs. This year, Trump’s businesses in Florida want to increase the number of foreign maids, waiters and cooks hired for seasonal jobs.
Recently, Kansas gubernatorial candidate Kris Kobach told a group in Wichita that the way to create jobs for Americans is to deport illegal aliens. How Kobach’s economic theories mesh with Trump’s claim that he can’t find American employees is unclear.
But a look at the Kansas labor situation provides good reason to think immigrants are part of the solution – not the primary problem – with the Kansas economy.
In June, according to state officials, Kansas’ unemployment rate was 3.4 percent. It was even lower in many western counties, where employers have trouble filling jobs. State officials also bemoan the lack of skilled labor in Wichita; they say businesses there can’t find enough qualified workers for jobs.
At the same time, the state’s labor pool – comprised of Kansans working or looking for work – continues to shrink. So as jobs grow, the number of Kansans who want them declines.
The numbers refute those who argue that the reason Americans can’t find or keep good jobs is because immigrants are being hired instead. And even though Trump’s own hiring practices reinforce that fact, the president and his supporters are adamant in their efforts to stop not only illegal immigration, but most permanent legal immigration as well.
Why they are so adamant might answered in a couple of ways.
Some of the president’s critics claim bigotry is a primary reason. They point out that most of Trump’s anti-immigration moves target Muslims and people of color. The report from the Washington Post notes that while immigration from Europe has increased slightly under Trump, numbers of immigrants from Africa, Muslim-majority nations and Central America have dropped significantly.
In contrast, Trump’s supporters point to American workers as the primary reason for current immigration policy. Like Kobach, they see a need to protect American jobs.
Their view is not shared by most economists, who think reductions in immigration will slow the economy.
“In general, the consensus of economists is that immigration on average has a strong positive effect on the American economy,” Giovanni Peri, the economics department chairman at the University of California at Davis, told the Post for its article. “The big picture really is that this cut in the number of all immigrants — high- and low-skill — is going to have an impact by slowing the economy.”
Perhaps Trump thinks more businesses should follow his lead: Bring foreign workers in temporarily, then ship them home when they don’t need them anymore.
That kind of labor force creates social tumult, as well as a class system that most Americans, at least in the past, have rejected.
The U.S. needs permanent workers who become part of our culture, even as they help shape it. We need an ever-changing, adaptive workforce to continue to be a vibrant yet stable economy.
In the past – despite some periods of anti-immigrant fervor – we have been that kind of country. We have been a nation where immigrants, regardless of their status or income, could build a better life for their families.
We are no longer that nation. And not only would-be immigrants will pay the price. We all will.