Help shape the next school funding law
In March 2015, Gov. Sam Brownback signed the law that eliminated Kansas’ funding plan for public schools.
Now, 18 months later, he has finally started work on a replacement plan.
Typically, government and business officials have a replacement ready before throwing out an old system. But not in Topeka, where conservative Republicans tried to outmaneuver the courts.
State legislators and Brownback trashed the funding formula in an effort to circumvent court rulings that found inequities in the way the state funded its schools. Their simplistic thinking: If there was no funding formula, how could it be unconstitutional?
The state Supreme Court didn’t fall for the ploy. But the irresponsible move left local school boards and administrators to navigate uncertain and unsound ground.
Development of a new school finance formula is complicated by ongoing court action. The Supreme Court still has not completed its rulings on the adequacy of funding for public schools.
While the court’s looming decision isn’t a minor consideration, it also is no excuse for failing to develop a reasonable plan for funding the state’s K-12 schools.
It’s not a task that takes 18 months. That fact is reflected in the governor’s approach. Brownback is now soliciting opinions and suggestions that presumably will be used to develop a new school finance formula within the next six months.
Skeptics might wonder whether the governor is just going through the motions of asking the public for ideas.
After all, Brownback and Republican leaders in the Legislature not only trashed the school funding plan, but in 2014 they eliminated many due process rights for public school teachers – in the middle of the night and without the usual hearings and committee consideration.
One of those leaders, Senate President Susan Wagle, now says she’s a champion of transparent and responsible state government.
Wagle has launched BETTER Kansas in an effort to appeal to moderate voters and colleagues. But if you visit Wagle’s website, betterkansasplan.com, you find the rhetoric is, at best, squishy.
One principle reads: “Senate Republicans … believe that we need to tax Kansas individuals and corporations at the lowest and most flat tax rate possible, that will allow the state to thrive.”
Here’s another: “Senate Republican nominees will make student achievement and progress our top priority. When we write a new school formula, we must provide flexibility in spending and long term stability for all school districts. We refuse to allow the one size fits all model we have seen fail in our federal government be implemented by liberal Democrats in Topeka. We believe in local control. Local school boards, teachers and parents should decide what is best for their schools. …”
Wagle and her website don’t say whether her coalition will reverse course on the income tax cuts that have blasted a huge and enduring hole in the state budget.
And they don’t say why lawmakers keep passing mandates for schools if they believe in local control.
What Wagle has said is that if the state Supreme Court rules that current school funding is inadequate, it would show that the judges are activists overstepping their role.
How does her “local control” rhetoric square with her belief that the court should automatically decide for the state, rather than possibly conclude that the local districts that initiated the lawsuit are correct?
BETTER Kansas appears to be a gimmick, a way for Wagle to feint a move to the middle and hang onto her leadership position.
Experience should make Kansans wary of rhetoric from Wagle and Brownback. Repeatedly, they have pushed unfair taxes and added debt, while cutting funds for public education, from kindergarten through college.
Their recent appeals to more moderate voters show they might be pressed to do what they claim they are doing – listening to the public.
So Kansans should take the governor and Senate president up on their offers and let them know what they’re thinking.
Contact the governor at StudentsFirst@ks.gov
The contact email provided at Wagle’s website is paje.resner@gmail.com
Firm and steady pressure applied by the public is our best chance of returning moderation and reason to state government.